How to Deal with Unrealistic Web Design Requests

A well-designed, intuitive and user-friendly website is an essential aspect of any modern business. It provides the first impression, acts as the virtual face of a company, and plays a significant role in its branding and marketing efforts. However, a common challenge many Web Designers, Web Developers, and creative and digital agencies face is the prevalence of unrealistic client requests. These can range from demanding unachievable deadlines and expecting overly complex designs that exceed budget limitations to requests that disregard web standards or best practices.

While it may seem a daunting task, knowing how to manage and respond to these unreasonable client requests effectively is crucial for the success and sanity of a Web Designer, Developer or agency. It will not only help you remain professional and maintain a healthy client relationship but it will also ensure the creation of a quality, feasible, and effective website in the end.

What Are Unrealistic Web Design Requests?

Before we dive into strategies for managing unrealistic client requests, it is important to define what exactly constitutes an ‘unrealistic’ request in the realm of web design.

1. Unreasonable Timelines:

Web design is a process that requires careful planning, execution, testing, and revisions. When clients demand tight turnaround times that don’t account for these necessary stages, the project scope and timeline can become unrealistic. For example:

• Expecting a fully functional e-commerce website with custom features to be ready within a week.
• Completely overhauling a website’s design, functionality, and content overnight.
• Expecting an instant turnaround for adding complex features such as a membership portal, e-commerce system or animations.
• Creating a website from scratch in a few days.

2. Overly Complex Designs Within Budget Constraints:

Many clients have grand visions for their websites but limited budgets. While it’s great to aim high, expecting a design comparable to big-budget websites with a fraction of the financial resources at disposal is not feasible. It is like expecting a Ferrari performance from a Punto. For example:

• Demanding high-end animation with a limited budget.
• Wanting a Custom CMS (Content Management System) on a shoestring.
• Expecting a website comparable to major brands with lean resources.

3. Misalignment with Web Standards or Best Practices:

This includes requests that compromise the usability, accessibility, or performance of the website, such as:

• Clients might want elements that could negatively impact the site’s loading speed or SEO, such as a website full of heavy animations, but expecting it to load instantaneously on all devices and browsers.
• They may request designs that look aesthetically pleasing but are not accessible to users with visual impairments.
• Or, they might insist on using a font or colour scheme that hampers readability or contrasts negatively with their brand identity.

Recognizing unrealistic and unreasonable requests when they appear is the first step in dealing with them effectively. In the next section, we will explore the impact of these requests and provide strategies to handle them.

The Impact of Unrealistic Requests

Understanding the potential impacts of unrealistic web design requests is key to appreciating the importance of effectively managing them. These impacts can be both immediate and long-term, and they not only affect the design team but also the client, and inevitably the end-user too. Here we have listed a few examples:

• Pressure on Web Designers and Developers: Unrealistic client requests can place an immense amount of pressure on Web Designers and Developers. Meeting unrealistic deadlines or creating overly complex designs within tight budget constraints can lead to stressful working conditions, overtime, and even burnout.
• Impact on Project Timeline and Deliverables: Unrealistic demands often lead to project delays, as they usually require more time and resources than initially planned. They can also lead to a reduction in the quality of deliverables if teams are forced to rush to meet impossible deadlines or to cut corners due to budget limitations.
• Potential Degradation of Website Quality or Performance: Requests that do not align with web standards or best practices can lead to a decrease in the website’s quality, usability, or performance. For example, a client’s insistence on particular design elements that slow page loading times can lead to a poor user experience, higher bounce rates, and lower SEO rankings.
• Long-term Repercussions: If agencies continuously agree to unrealistic requests, it can set a dangerous precedent, leading to a cycle of overpromising and underdelivering. It can negatively impact a Web Designer’s or agency’s reputation and relationships with clients.

Understanding the wide-reaching impacts of unreasonable requests can help underscore the importance of managing these more effectively, and most clients will readily get on board with a robust web design brief process.

Strategies to Tackle Unrealistic Client Requests

When confronted with unrealistic web design requests, it’s crucial to remain calm, stay professional and approach them strategically. Here are some strategies that can help:

1. Open Communication and Managing Client Expectations:

• Discussing the Feasibility of the Request: First, have an open conversation with your client about the feasibility of their request. This may include explaining the time, resources, and expertise required to fulfil their request and why it may not be possible within their current parameters.
• Educating Clients About the Web Design Process: Clients may have unrealistic expectations simply because they are not familiar with the web design process. Educate them about the various stages involved, from conceptualization and design to development, testing, and revisions and involve them in every stage of your web design brief.

2. Brush Up On Your Negotiation Skills

• Tips for Successful Negotiation: Mastering negotiation skills is crucial in this scenario. This includes empathizing with the client, understanding their needs, offering alternatives, and finding a middle ground.
• Draw on Your Previous Experience: Use real-life examples or case studies that illustrate how negotiation has led to a successful outcome in a similar situation.

3. Setting Clear Boundaries and Standing Your Ground

• Learn to Say ‘No’: It is essential to set clear boundaries with clients and not be afraid to say ‘no’ when a request is truly unrealistic. This can be challenging, but it is vital for maintaining the quality of your work and the health of your staff and business.
• Explain the Consequences: Detail the potential implications of the client’s request, whether they are related to budget, timeline, or the overall quality of the website. This can help the client understand why their request might not be feasible or beneficial in the long run.
• Implement a ‘Scope Change Request’ Process: If a client is constantly asking for changes or additions that were not initially agreed upon, implement a formal process where they have to submit a ‘Scope Change Request’. This request overhauls the original project’s scope and details the changes they want. You can then provide an analysis of how it would impact the project in terms of cost, timeline, and resources.

4. Alternative Solutions and Compromises

• Offer Alternatives: Instead of saying ‘no’, propose to the client alternative solutions that achieve their objectives without overstepping their budget or timelines. This could include phased development (delivering the project in stages), utilizing existing tools or platforms, or simplifying the design without compromising the overall user experience.
• Suggest a Compromise: Find a middle ground that suits both parties. If a client wants a complex feature added immediately, suggest implementing a basic version first and enhancing it over time.
• Use the ‘Yes, but…’ Technique: This method involves acknowledging the client’s request, and then adding a ‘but’ to introduce your concerns or alternative suggestions. For example, ‘Yes, we could add a video background to every page of your website, but this might significantly slow down the page load times and affect user experience. Instead, we could use a video background only on the homepage and use optimized images on the rest of the pages.’

Remember, the goal is to reach a solution that satisfies the client while also being achievable and realistic for the design and development team. This often involves a balance of education, negotiation, and creative problem-solving.

Turning Unrealistic Requests Into Opportunities

While unrealistic requests can pose challenges, they may also present unique opportunities for growth, learning, and strengthening client relationships. Here’s how:

1. Educate Clients

Use these situations as an opportunity to educate your clients about the intricacies of web design. By understanding the time, effort, and resources that go into creating a website, clients may be more inclined to adjust their expectations and value your expertise more.

2. Demonstrate Expertise and Value

When you explain why a certain request is unrealistic and suggest more practical alternatives, you are demonstrating your expertise and value. This can position you as not just a service provider, but as a knowledgeable consultant who can guide clients to make better decisions.

3. Building Stronger Client Relationships

Dealing with a difficult situation effectively can actually strengthen your relationship with a client. When you navigate these challenges with professionalism and a focus on problem-solving, you show the client that you are committed to finding the best solution for their needs. This can foster trust and mutual respect, which are invaluable in any business relationship.

Ultimately, these ‘unrealistic’ requests can be reframed as opportunities for demonstrating your professionalism, expertise, and commitment to the client’s needs. Handling these situations effectively can not only resolve the current issue but also prevent similar challenges in the future.

Implementing a Process for Managing Requests

To effectively deal with unrealistic requests on a consistent basis, it is crucial to have a robust process in place. Taking a good web design brief is a critical part of establishing this process. It helps in managing client expectations and handling unrealistic requests from the get-go and establishing clear communication lines. Here’s a simple web design brief process you can adopt:

1. Initial Client Meeting/Discovery Phase:

• Understand Client’s Needs and Expectations: In your initial meetings, focus on thoroughly understanding the client’s needs, expectations, and understanding of the web design process.
• Educate About the Web Design Process: Explain your process, the timeframes typically involved, and what each stage entails. Involve your client throughout every stage of your web design brief.
• Discuss Budget and Scope: Have an open conversation about the client’s budget and what it can realistically achieve. It is crucial to ensure the client’s expectations align with their budget and timeframe.

2. Proposal Stage:

• Detailed Scope of Work: Include a detailed scope of work in your proposal, outlining what will be delivered, the timelines, and the costs involved. The more detailed, the less room there is for confusion or unrealistic add-on requests later.
• Revision Policies: Clearly mention your policies around revisions, including how many revisions are included in the initial cost and what happens if the client exceeds these.

3. During the Project:

• Regular Updates and Check-ins: Regularly update your client about the progress of the project and any potential roadblocks. This can help manage their expectations and give them an opportunity to voice any concerns early on.
• Handle Unrealistic Requests as They Come: If a client makes an unrealistic request during the project, refer back to the initial scope of work in your web design brief, discuss the implications (in terms of time, cost, and quality), and negotiate a solution that works for both parties.

4. Project Closure:

• Review the Project: At the end of the project, review the process with your client. Discuss what went well and any areas for improvement. This feedback can help you refine your process for other clients and future projects.

This process isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution, but it provides a solid starting point. You can adjust and improve upon it based on your experiences and the specific needs of your clients.

How to Take A Web Design Brief

If you are looking for a game-changing resource to steer your web design projects towards success every time, look no further!

My upcoming new book ‘How to Take a Web Design Brief’ is born out of my own experience of working in the creative industries, spanning over a decade. This book is a comprehensive guide, a strategic toolset packed with industry secrets, and all the things I wish I knew, for creating precise, goal-oriented web design briefs that ensure a successful outcome every time.

Create Happy Clients

Whether you are an established Web Designer, Web Developer or a newcomer in the field, this book offers valuable insights and step-by-step guidance that will elevate your web design projects to a new level. Packed with clear instructions, relatable examples, and lessons drawn from my own real-world experiences, this guide will equip you to streamline your web design process, optimize time and budget, consistently deliver top-quality products and ultimately, create happy clients.